Is raw meat good for you? The science behind the controversial diet

Rising energy and gas prices might make you think twice about firing up your stove for a roast or stew. Why cook that meat? After all, your menu could include trendy beef carpaccio, flavorsome wild boar’s liver, coppa, or pancetta. If you learned to like raw meat, you might become a paleo-keto-carnivorous pilgrim with visions of developing a ripped torso.

Humans are omnivores: we can digest raw meat and thrive. The Inuit, among others living in frozen latitudes, eat raw meat from seals, caribou, elk, or whale. Uncooked cuts from horses, chickens, and goats are presented as small delicacies on tables from Europe to Japan. While some bodybuilders promote raw meat and offal diets (carefully selected).

Raw meat has also been used as medicine. In the late 19th century, French doctors suggested it as a treatment for tuberculosis.

It seemed successful, sometimes. But the researchers described two problems. First, obtaining clean raw meat was difficult. Second, their patients disliked their daily dose of half a pound of raw meat. Treatments were adjusted to using the meat juice instead. This “zomotherapy” was more popular and, they said, less likely to cause tapeworm infections.

Raw liver therapy for pernicious anemia was investigated by George Minot and William Murphy. They received the Nobel prize in 1934 for this pioneering work that paved the way for isolating vitamin B12. B12 is stored in a herbivore’s liver and damaged by cooking. These early studies all showed that raw meat came with some dangers from infection and infestation.

Microbial hazards

The animals we eat share this planet with us. We are all surrounded by an amazing diversity of uncountable microbes, some of which may be shared at mealtimes. A tempting piece of raw meat, therefore, requires elaborate checking. Has it any prions, viruses, bacteria, fungi, or parasites?

Although many of these critters are harmless, some are quite lethal unless treated. Some, such as prion-linked brain diseases, cannot be treated. And some will treat us as their food. If that steak is venison from your recent hunt, its pathogens will be different compared to a farm-reared steer.

The bacteria Escherichia coli, for example, were thought harmless when described in 1885. Up to 50 percent of healthy cattle may carry E. coli 0157. These are resistant to our stomach acid; their Shiga toxins can cause kidney failure, shock, and death.

Listeria is named after Joseph Lister, the father of surgical sterilization. It is a skilled soil organism that can multiply on a steak in your fridge, then infect your bloodstream and brain, or cross a placenta resulting in miscarriage and fetal death.

Beef can be contaminated with Toxoplasmosis gondii, a protozoal parasite from cats that happily survive in cattle and humans. Toxoplasmosis tends to find its way into the brain, retina, heart muscle, or cross the placenta, where it can damage the foetal brain. Some of these effects may take years to become evident; you would probably not notice anything after that raw lunch.

Although there are no proven advantages to eating raw meat, there are great microbial hazards. (Feeding your pets raw meat has similar risks.) Not only is there a risk of being infected with Campylobacters and Salmonellas, but also parasites such as roundworms and tapeworms.

The passion — in some quarters — for returning to a habit of consuming raw meat should be checked against the facts of “one health” — that is, taking into consideration the combined health of people, animals, and our environments.

We are not alone. Many, many microbes, usually checked by safe food management and cooking, would just love us to take up a wolverine lifestyle.

This article was originally published on The Conversation by Colin Michie Nab at the University of Central Lancashire. Read the original article here.